The Pawtucket Brewery needs the following items to craft new decorations and prizes.

Bottle Caps (uncommon) from Peter, Quagmire and Seamus
Empty Beer Bottles (uncommon) from Meg, Herbert and Lois
Beer Bubbles (rare) from Vinny and Bruce, Stewie and Connie
Silver Patriot Tickets (rare) from Tom Tucker, Carter and Mort
Tap-Handle Cane (extra rare) from Mayor West, Tricia and Dr. Hartman