Santa Hats are used to battle Mutant Elf and can be obtained in the following ways:
- Making Stewie Make a Snowman
- Making Jerome Prepare Eggnog
- Making Prince Cleveland Star in a Holiday Special
- Making Sexy Santa Peter Lick a Candy Cane
- Making Krampus Brick Baker Shear Himself
- Making Krampus Brick Baker Put a Christmas Tree in the Courtroom