Black Eyeliners are used to investigate Away Rooms and can be obtained in the following ways:
- Making Consuela Make a Mix CD
- Making Mort Fill Insulin Prescriptions
- Making Carter Listen to the Radio
- Making Connie Scrunch Her Hair
- Making Lois Wear Wrist Sweatbands
- Making Krampus Brick Baker Play Emo Music for Kids
- From Emo Nightclub